Recycling Europe Challenges EUROFER and European Aluminium Over EU Scrap Export Curbs
By Zamir Kahn, Journalist
updated:
European recyclers have objected to steel and aluminium producers’ support for tougher EU controls on scrap exports, arguing that the restrictions could serve as market protection rather than advance environmental goals.
In response to the European Commission’s draft delegated act, Eurofer, the steel association, and European Aluminium this week endorsed the creation of a register of non-OECD countries eligible to receive non-hazardous waste shipments from the EU under the updated Waste Shipment Regulation (WSR). They urged tighter export monitoring, describing ferrous and aluminium scrap as strategic secondary raw materials essential to the EU’s decarbonisation efforts.
The organisations also said exports should go only to countries able to demonstrate that they meet environmentally sound standards for waste management and recycling.
Recyclers Push Back on Export Limits
But Recycling Europe criticised that position on 17 November, arguing proposed restrictions would reduce competition, limit access to international markets and depress prices paid to recyclers. It said the measures risk treating scrap as a protected industrial feedstock rather than a globally traded secondary raw material.

Recycling Europe said export limits would not necessarily increase consumption in Europe because its members already process most of the steel and aluminium scrap they collect. Exports mainly provide an outlet for surplus material that domestic demand cannot absorb. It argued that manufacturers seeking to keep more scrap in Europe should commit to buying and using it, and that recycled-content mandates would do more to increase demand for secondary raw materials than restrictions on recyclers’ access to export markets.
Recycling Needs Demand, Not Restrictions
Environmental goals should not be used to shield markets. EUROFER and European Aluminium describe the export of recycled metals as a way for Europe to shift its pollution elsewhere. That account overlooks the fact that, in most cases, recycling has already taken place in Europe. Recycling steel and aluminium uses less energy than primary production, cuts emissions and conserves raw materials. Casting recycling as an environmental problem obscures its vital role in decarbonisation and efficient resource use.
Requiring recycled content under EU legislation would create the dependable demand that recycled materials need. But restricting exports alone will not generate buyers in Europe: domestic markets cannot absorb all the recycled metal already available to European recycling businesses. Figures show that our members keep the vast majority of the steel and aluminium they recycle within the EU, exporting only around 20% because local demand is too weak. Industries calling for restrictions have not promised to buy the material those measures would keep in Europe. Manufacturers wanting more scrap to stay in Europe should commit to purchasing and using it rather than preventing recyclers from selling to other customers.
Viable Recyclers Build Secure Supply
Manufacturers can secure a dependable supply of recycled metals only if recyclers can operate sustainably. That requires revenue sufficient to cover transport, energy, labour, equipment, and the costs of collecting, sorting, and processing scrap. Prices that do not cover these costs would make recycling operations unviable. Export restrictions may temporarily lower manufacturers’ feedstock costs, but they would weaken the collection and processing networks those manufacturers need. Scrap that nobody can afford to handle is no usable resource.
The same environmental standards should apply to scrap entering and leaving the EU. EU metal producers should not demand stricter scrutiny of recycled metal exports while ignoring the standards governing the collection and processing of imported scrap.
Demand-boosting policies—including recycled-content targets, green public procurement, and circular VAT measures—can give recyclers the confidence to invest. Manufacturers that want reliable supplies of recycled materials should likewise support efforts to use more recycled content. A circular value chain requires cooperation and shared commitment, not conflict.
Competitive Markets Benefit the Entire Value Chain
- Recycling Europe says a competitive market should benefit the entire value chain.
- Europe’s industrial competitiveness will not improve if recyclers are denied market access and cannot count on buyers for their output, the group says.
- Metal producers seeking reliable supplies in the future should not undermine today’s suppliers, Recycling Europe says.
- European manufacturers need recycled materials, while recyclers need customers; neither can thrive at the other’s expense.
- To boost domestic uptake, Recycling Europe urges the European Commission to address high energy costs, weak demand and inadequate processing capacity.
- Environmental laws should ensure compliance rather than serve as market protection, the group says.
- Recycling Europe calls for impartial, evidence-based decisions focused on environmental compliance rather than particular industries’ commercial interests.
- Materials that meet the EU’s end-of-waste criteria should retain that legal status, the group says.